We did something remarkable at our church on Sunday. Had a harvest festival with no harvest. No loaves, no fruit; not so much as a tin of beans on a window ledge.
It seems our clergy have been having a re-think. One of them spent his entire sermon trying to sell it to us.
Now, advancing years be damned – I can accept evolution. The harvest isn’t the landmark occasion it was 150 years ago. Mechanisation lulls all of us into thinking that this stuff just happens and food arrives on our table by magic. Gone are the days when I expect to walk into church one September morning and see wheat sheaves piled up everywhere.
All it needed on Sunday was a single table, visible to all as we approached the altar for communion, piled up with food, tinned and fresh, all of it designated for the food bank or other good home once the service was over.
A simple visual prod that would see most of us through for another year, as it always has. No, this does not appear by magic. Yes, we are luckier than we know. So no, we will not waste food in the coming 12 months. We will clear our plates. We will count our blessings.
If you’re going to change all that, it has to involve metamorphosis into something better, more relevant, not just some U-turn up a cassocked rear end. Apparently, this year’s harvest festival, we were to regard as a ‘harvest of hearts’. We were invited to write three personal qualities, for which we’re thankful and which we can use for the good of others, on a paper heart, which we were then to stick onto a naff cardboard wall as we headed for the altar.
I declined. This is my life from now on, I suspect: a series of small ‘up yours’ protests that might be noticeable only to me but which nevertheless make me feel rather better than the nonsense I’m protesting.
I could take the hard line and assume that someone’s vicar just couldn’t be bothered this year, but that would be harsh. He seems hard-working enough to be above that.
No, more likely is that weakness to which too many Anglican clergy are prone. Replace something tangible with an abstract nebula like ‘harvest of hearts’ and they just can’t resist. Something woolly and vague that they can talk about endlessly, from all sorts of tangents, because none of it’s real, so none of it really matters.
It might make them feel lovely inside but its capacity for putting bums on seats, I suspect, is rather more limited.
Related: An opportunity missed, Church of England